>>Wednesday December 13, 2006
Study: Most Self-Diagnosed "Asperger's" Patients Just Assholes

OXFORD, ENGLAND- For 20-year-old college student Annie Soshul, learning about Asperger's Syndrome was like opening a door. The symptoms of the disorder, not unlike a mild form of autism, sounded like her own autobiography: a gift for mathematics, an obsession with detail, and extreme discomfort with personal interaction or intimacy.

For years Soshul wondered what was wrong with her. Although her online life was rich and fulfilling, her "real life" inability to get along with coworkers or maintain a romantic relationship had become a source of deep frustration. At long last she was now armed with a medical term for her peculiar and often abrasive personality. For the first time since early childhood, she felt comfortable in her own skin.

She is by no means alone. There are, according to the most recent estimate, millions of young people today who so fervently believe that the disorder explains who and what they are that they see no need to seek medical attention to confirm their condition, much less to treat it.

According to a new study in the current issue of The Lancet, however, Soshul and others may be completely off base. After rummaging through piles of data spanning years of clinical research, the study's authors have concluded that a majority of these self-diagnosed Asperger's patients are actually just intensely unlikable people.

They are, in short, assholes.

"I took the on-line 'do you have Asperger's' test from that Slashdot link, and I scored near the top," said Soshul. "The result said that I'm smart and that my lack of people skills is a gift rather than a sign of ineptitude. These researchers can say all they want, but nobody can take that away from me."

Over the course of the past year, this "Do you have Asperger's Syndrome" quiz has circulated on the Internet more than "dumb blonde jokes" and "drowned lawyer jokes" emails combined. In fact, people take so much pride in their high scores that some have dubbed it the Mensa test of the new millennium. Not surprisingly, the revelation that these self-aggrandizing tests have no diagnostic value has not gone over well.

Dr. Leon McCouch says that he and the rest of the research team fully understood that their work might be controversial but were completely surprised at the torrent of hatemail and online death threats that followed its publication.

"It was never our intent to insult or upset people," said McCouch. "But as medical professionals, we would be remiss in our duty if we were to stand by and allow these people to incorrectly tie their boorish behavior to Asperger's Syndrome. Then again, I suppose we should have anticipated this reaction. What else would you expect when you speak truth to a bunch of assholes?"

McCouch went on to explain that his group's intention is to encourage folks who feel they have Asperger's to get tested for the disorder. For most of these people, however, the desire for an official diagnosis is grossly outweighed by the very real possibility that they will be told that they don't have Asperger's Syndrome.

The explanation has done little to calm nerves online. E-petitions for the article's redaction, profanity-laden rants, and amateurish Photoshops of McCouch circulated throughout the web on Tuesday.

"What right have they to take my Asperger's away from me?" wrote N1ght3lPh. "I'm so mad about this, I think I might post a thread about it."

Under intense pressure, McCouch has agreed to write a follow-up to the article for the next issue declaring a new medical definition for the not-quite-Asperger's-Syndrome Syndrome that appears to be spreading so quickly among America's 20-somethings. The disorder, to be known as "Ass Burger's Syndrome" should become official by February or March of next year.

The designation represents a significant step forward for wannabe Asperger's patients and their families, though experts say that it could just be a code name doctors will use to subtly mock Internet-addicted young people with no social skills.

--
(54 Votes)

Bush to Override FDA Decision, Push Instead for "Plan P"

"Aw, She's Fugly. I Want My Amnesia Back!"

ESRB Re-Designates Game From "Nerdy" to "Socially Retarded"

WARNING: MyCrawlSpace May Be Unsafe For Teens, Toddlers

Comments (22)( 1 2  )Post Comment
 PetrKunkAlpinist1977  (57 Days Ago)
Da haste dir aber viel mühe gegeben Den Eiger in 2,47 Stunden zu besteigen währe wohl vor 70Jahren nicht moeglich gewesen Respekt Ueli Steck!

 izmyaspieshowin  (107 Days Ago)
I am an aspie, I know this for sure, because it is the only thing that makes sense to answer all the questions I've always had about why people don't like me, why I don't understand any social situation, why I'm obsessive about everything, and I can't feel emotions the right way. I am not an asshole, I am kind, polite, gentle, love my kids, etc. I know that way too many people are hearing about it and calling themselves aspies, people will always find some loophole to be lazy and stupid, it is our nature. I don't adhere to that. I have fought way too hard my whole life trying to understand what is normal and why am I unable to be that. I am 24/7 awkward, even though I've tried to get better at social conversation, I am just always off somehow. I do want to get officially diagnosed, my son is going to be as well, he is not right, very similar to me, and so is my father, though he won't admit it. I guess it isn't one thing that makes me think I am aspie, it is the overwhelming weight of symptoms, no social skills, sensitivity to everything (light, noise, texture, smells, pain) that others don't even notice, and perpetual "writer's block" every day when trying to work, I'm affected adversely by weather, etc. I think people who write articles like this are selling something, they could care less about who it affects. It is all about being honest with yourself and other around you. Self-diagnosis seems like the only alternative at times, since an aspie like me can't communicate well with anyone outside my head, and I've learned behaviors so I can appear more normal and try to blend in, so I am not so bullied about it constantly, so it can be hard to tell. I know that I don't know myself as well as I think, and I keep trying to run from aspie's as the cause, but it is still after much research the only thing that explains my behavior, others behavior, and why I just don't understand life.

 richelle  (117 Days Ago)
I meant to say "i can't even *leave* my house"

 richelle  (117 Days Ago)
What kind of doctor rants like that? This article IS ridiculous. I've had Asperger's my entire life. It used to be much harder when I was a young kid due to the fact that I had no life experience. Over time, I've come to understand how the NT mind works (not fully), and so have adapted to society. I don't really have a choice. Most people think I'm completely normal, but I'm far from... I remember asking my mom once when I was in grade 7 "Mom, am I handicapped, and everyone knows this but me?" I just couldn't figure out why no one liked me, and why I knew I was different. I think there's a difference between "assholes", and those who are perceived as assholes but who aren't trying to be. I used to say things to kids that was insensitive and rude, and had NO idea why everyone hated me for it until years later... simple social norms that any 'normal' person would just 'get'. Anxiety is so pervasive in my life I can't even lease my house unless I have a purpose. It's so beautiful outside right now, but I have nothing to do, so I can't go outside! It sucks because I'm cooped up in my house. Another anxiety agent is the fact that I'm supposedly aesthetically superior to other humans. This creates ATTENTION which I don't like when I'm by myself... I start to sweat, and my GI tract starts acting up... this is every single day. I'm always in fight or flight mode... it's so draining! But I am PROUD to be an Aspergian. I am smart, intellectual, and believe I possess a certain kind of consciousness which most (and I meant MOST) NTs do not possess. :-)

sillyme  (136 Days Ago)
jee..you know, i don't see why actual autistics should get up in arms about people who complain about jerks who claim aspbergers as their excuse for being jerks. i personally am undiagnosable (years and many psychs), and i was pre-med in college, and psych is a hobby. i think the whole enchilada needs to be revised, is on the wrong footing. but, in current vernacular, i would claim schizo. yet, firmly grounded in what western culture glibly purports as "reality." there is some cultural bias here. (anthro background, too.) Also important to study philosophy. gee whiz. get a grip, honey.mean people are mean, if you can't make 'em better, toss 'em outta the tribe. that's the old way.

Selenya  (136 Days Ago)
Totally. I knew this jerkwad guy (who claimed to be transexual, but who I think is just Peter Griffin in a dress and make-up) who used Asperger's as her excuse to be a f-ing a-hole. She would act sweet at first...but then scream at the top of her lungs if her computer was slow. she would start fights with neighbors, neighbor's dogs, coffee baristas, store clerks, waitpersons. then she would cry and whine when people callled the police on her for assualt, then blame her syndrome on her childhood. boo hoo hoo. i have a screwed up beyond belief childhood, and i an OK, and positive, and working to better myself and the world at all times. but this asperger fake seems to thrive on one emotion: anger!!!!!!! yuk. i do not believe in aspebergers. it is assholebergers. i also think adhd is a fraud, an excuse for lazy parents to deny the fact that they are bad parents and their kids are BORED out their minds, and not loved and supported. boo-yah!

NORMAL  (167 Days Ago)
*Sperg*

the real deal  (227 Days Ago)
I got medically diagnosed, and it was quite a shock as i had been there for an eating disorder(which is rare in lads), i felt i'd been misdiagnosed. I'm from the uk where its not as well known, but definetely in the usa, people seem to be using as a solution or coping method, its kinda insulting and will really f*** up those who actually have the condition;s reputations, and seeing as most aspies have no confidence at all, that really would be s***ty

Norm Awl  (242 Days Ago)
I hate the term "Aspie" and I hate the losers who proudly label themselves as such. Most of them are only moderately bright and yet they carry on like they're geniuses who need to be treated with awe and respect. If you play role-playing games on the computer all day and you have no real-life friends you're a loser, not as Aspie.

Abby  (255 Days Ago)
[comment deleted because the commenter doesn't understand the enormous difference between the word "some" and the word "all."]

Common Sense  (317 Days Ago)
Are you guys kidding me, those sources are fake. calm down

Anonymous  (359 Days Ago)
I AM SELF DIAGNOSED! and I also agree there seem's to be a lot of self diags about (USA due to cost). But their is a paradox here, if one is a true Aspire, then when this new intense interest would lead to ALLOT of research (in AS) and the symptoms are very specific despite only being a qualitative effect in each area, I would be more inclined to assume until proven non-AS. I am seeking a true pro Dx not for a label, but to gain a better understanding of why I am.

Caroline  (655 Days Ago)
Annie Soshul? Leon McCouch? Clever spoof, guys. But I agree that Aspergers has become the trendy disorder of the day.

April  (733 Days Ago)
I COMPLETELY agree with this article, this practically mirrors my own personal feelings on the title "aspergers" I feel it is waaay overdiagnosed and I don't understand how people can be "proud" to be "aspies" My view is that those who think or even those who "do" have aspergers are a combination of the following: narcissistic, OCD, and have anxiety problems. And then what REALLY pisses me off is those who have aspergers trying to make it worse than it is and saying they're autistic. Nooo they are two different things, if they weren't you would not have the capacity to sit and make ignorant web posts.

Admittedly Reactionary Aspie  (821 Days Ago)
You know who else are assholes? Assholes like me.

Finabhair  (856 Days Ago)
You would not be the first to call it ASSberger syndrome. For those who truly have it, it is a serious disorder, the rest of the wannabees are nothing but attention seekers who take away from the seriousness of families who duffer with this disorder. What annoys me is the people who insist they are Aspies and also insist they have empathy, loads of friends and never have any trouble getting a date. You can't have Asperger's if you don't have any of the symptoms and the symptoms include, poor social skills, lack of empathy and problems with abstract thinking.

 Ettina  (882 Days Ago)
There are some self-diagnosed people who really aren't on the Spectrum, but when you think that many of these people tend to be obsessive and research things a lot, if a high functioning autistic person obsesses on autism they will probably soon know more about autism than many professionals. I was a self-diagnosed aspie (now officially diagnosed) and one professional told me after a brief conversation that I couldn't be on the autistic spectrum if I spoke as well as I do without any therapy. And being an asshole presents very differently from Asperger Syndrome, if you know anything about AS you can easily tell the difference. Also, there are plenty of reasons a self-diagnosed person may not seek official diagnosis, beyond knowing they're not really AS. Firstly, it may not be that important. I was homeschooled when I first called myself autistic, and whether or not I was officially diagnosed didn't matter - just understanding my autistic traits better. I was officially diagnosed when I went back to school for grade 10 and needed accomodation. Many self-diagnosed autistics are adults living on their own who either don't need accomodation, or are unlikely to get it even if diagnosed (because there are no services for highly verbal developmentally disabled people with self-care problems). Secondly, they may have been misdiagnosed a lot or had other bad experiences leaving them with no faith in psychologists. There are autistics who've been called schizophrenic, all sorts of things like that, and gotten very damaging treatment. It takes a lot of bravery, after all that, to go to a psychologist for any reason. Also, doctors sometimes react to someone saying 'I think I have such-and-such' by trying to find any possible explanation *other* than what the person suggested, even if they have to distort facts to do so. For example, I also have hypermobility (excessively mobile joints) which causes joint pain. Months before I was diagnosed, I had gone to the doctor with pain in my legs, especially my ankles, and told him I thought I might have hypermobility. He told me I couldn't have that because hypermobile people have knee pain, and proceeded to completely ignore me when I replied that I actually do have knee pain. And ankle pain seems to be more typical of hypermobility than knee pain, from what I've read. Thirdly, some autistics fear that the diagnosis will be used against them. Michelle Dawson, an autistic researcher, was fired by Canada Post when she told them she was autistic.

Donald  (897 Days Ago)
I think this article is a bit harsh. Almost anything people do to be 'boorish' to another person is more than likely becuase of their own pain from not fitting into this hard to fit-in-able post industrial society of ours. There is a proactive way to try and inform people that inter personal relationships are important and not to always take themselves so seriously. This is just sarcastic and 'boorish' in its own right. I do however agree that one should not try to use some medical term as an excuse to not fit in.

scet  (906 Days Ago)
[deleted: no copy-paste screeds, please]

sarah  (919 Days Ago)
I have taken the test and was afforded a whopping score. I AM NOT AN ASSHOLE IM A REALLY NICE PERSON!!! I care about other people I just find it very hard to understand and relate to them. I actually took the test after my son was diagnosed with severe autism and Ive not been able to cope with teaching him skills that I don't have myself. I would like to know how I can get an official dignosis so I can get the help I DESPERATELY NEED!!!

Name: Email (Optional):

 

 


Chuck Charleston Wants to Help You.